Chess and children’s thinking: what the studies really show

Chess is a wonderful game for planning and learning from losses. Here is what the research says, and does not say, about chess and school results.

For grown-ups3 min readEvidence: A plausible use of broader research
A child thinking through a choice while an adult waits patiently.

Why this matters

Chess has a reputation as a “smart game.” Many parents hear that chess will raise math scores or IQ. Some schools have added chess lessons for that reason. It is worth knowing what the research actually found, so you can enjoy chess for the right reasons.

The short answer: chess is a rich thinking game, and many children love it. But careful studies have not shown that chess lessons raise school test scores.

What chess practices

Chess asks a child to slow down and look ahead. Before each move, a player can ask: What is my plan? What will my opponent do next? Is anything of mine in danger? After a loss, a player can look back: Where did it go wrong? What would I try next time?

Those are useful habits in any game. They also give a child many small chances to lose, recover and try again, in a setting with clear rules.

What the research says

A 2016 review pooled 24 studies of chess lessons in school (source 1). On average, children who had chess lessons did a bit better on school and thinking measures. But none of the studies had an ideal design. The authors judged that the real-world benefit was uncertain.

A much larger and stronger study followed. In England, more than 4,000 children aged 9 and 10 in about 100 schools took part in a randomized trial (source 2). Some schools replaced one lesson a week with a year of chess lessons from trained tutors. A year later, there was no effect on math, reading or science test scores. Half of the children said they liked the lessons a lot.

Two smaller experiments compared chess with other board games, such as checkers or Go (source 3). They found no clear difference in math problem solving. The authors concluded that any effects are modest and that chess should not replace math teaching.

What the research does not say

  • It does not say chess is a waste of time. The trials measured test scores. They did not measure enjoyment, confidence or friendship.
  • It does not test children who choose to play at home for fun.
  • It does not show that chess raises general intelligence.

How to make chess a good habit

  • Play together. A grown-up, sibling or grandparent makes a great opponent.
  • Review one move, not the whole game. Ask, “What else did you think about playing?”
  • Praise the thinking. “You looked at my bishop before you moved. Nice.”
  • Keep losses light. Shake hands, say “good game,” and set up again.
  • Use puzzles. Short puzzles are great on busy days and build the habit of looking ahead.
  • Track progress gently. A rating that grows with play can be motivating. Keep it about chess only, not about the child.

Signs it is going well

  • Your child pauses before moving.
  • Your child can explain one choice.
  • Your child recovers after a loss and wants to play again.
  • Your child begins to notice the other player’s threats.

Try it this week

Play three short games with your child. After each one, look at a single move together. Ask, “Was there another move you almost played? Why did you choose this one?” Then let your child ask you the same question about your moves.

Sources and how far they apply

  1. Do the benefits of chess instruction transfer to academic and cognitive skills? A meta-analysis (Sala and Gobet, Educational Research Review 18, 46-57, 2016). About structured chess lessons in school. None of the 24 studies had an ideal design, so real-world benefit is uncertain.
  2. Does teaching children how to play cognitively demanding games improve their educational attainment? Evidence from a randomised controlled trial of chess instruction in England (Jerrim, Macmillan, Micklewright, Sawtell and Wiggins (UCL Institute of Education), funded by the Education Endowment Foundation, 2018). A randomized trial of whole-class chess lessons for children aged 9 and 10 in England. It does not test playing at home by choice.
  3. Does chess instruction improve mathematical problem-solving ability? Two experimental studies with an active control group (Sala and Gobet, Learning & Behavior, 2017). Two small school experiments with third and fourth graders.

Sources were checked when this article was written. This article is general education, not medical, diagnostic or legal advice.

Coming soon: MySoarBoard

The Foundation is building a home–school learning board for children in kindergarten through grade 3 that puts ideas like this into daily practice. See what is inside or request an early peek (opens the Foundation's website).