How we label research on this site

Every article and every part of MySoarBoard carries one of three evidence labels. Here is what each label means, and why we say where the research stops.

For grown-ups3 min read
A parent and a teacher discussing a notebook together.

Why this matters

Parents and teachers hear many claims about learning products. “Proven.” “Research-based.” “Brain-boosting.” Some of those claims are careful. Many are not. It can be hard to tell the difference.

We want you to be able to check our work. So every article on this site, and every part of MySoarBoard, carries one of three plain labels. Each article also lists its sources, with a note on how far each one applies.

The three labels

Well-supported teaching practice. Strong research supports this practice in settings close to the one we describe. Example: using behavior ratings to give children feedback is rated strong evidence in a major U.S. guide for kindergarten to grade 5 teachers (source 1).

A plausible use of broader research. Good research supports a related idea, and we are applying it in a new setting, such as at home or in an app. The application makes sense, but it has not been tested itself. Example: using specific praise alongside small rewards at home draws on classroom guidance and on a large review of rewards and interest (sources 1 and 2).

An idea that still needs testing. We think the activity is worthwhile, but we have not found research that tests it. We say so plainly. Example: building in a small 3D block world.

What we promise

  • We say what an activity is for, not that it is proven to raise scores, IQ or behavior.
  • We do not claim that any university, agency or researcher endorses our work.
  • We do not give medical or diagnostic advice.
  • We describe ratings and points as what happened, not as how capable a child is.
  • We tell you when a study does not fit. If a study looked at teenagers, older students, classrooms in another country, or a different activity, we say so.

An example of saying where the research stops

Chess is a good example. Many people believe chess lessons raise school grades. A large randomized trial of more than 4,000 children aged 9 and 10 in England found no effect on math, reading or science test scores (source 3). We still love chess as a thinking game. We just do not promise it will raise grades.

How to read a “source” note

At the end of each article, you will find:

  • The title and author of each source, with a link.
  • The year.
  • How far it applies, in one or two sentences. This tells you who was studied, where, and what the source can and cannot show.

Some sources are formal studies. Others are practical guides or papers from education organizations. Practical papers can be very useful, but they are not experiments, and we label them that way.

Why this matters for MySoarBoard

MySoarBoard, the home–school learning board the Foundation is developing, has not yet been tested in a study. We plan to ask independent researchers to evaluate it. Until then, we describe what each part is for and what the research behind it does and does not say. You can see every part and its label on the MySoarBoard page.

Questions or corrections

If you find a source that changes what we say, or a mistake in how we describe one, please tell us through the Foundation’s contact page. We would rather be corrected than be wrong.

Try it yourself

The next time you see a learning product that says “proven,” ask three questions. Proven to do what? For whom? Compared with what? Those three questions will tell you a lot.

Sources and how far they apply

  1. Teacher-Delivered Behavioral Interventions in Grades K-5: A Practice Guide for Educators (WWC 2025001) (What Works Clearinghouse, U.S. Institute of Education Sciences (panel chaired by Kathleen Lynne Lane, December 2024). Written for K–5 classroom teachers; it is about school behavior, not home websites, and it does not cover intensive interventions.
  2. A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation (Deci, Koestner and Ryan, Psychological Bulletin 125(6), 627-668, 1999). Mostly short lab and school experiments. A reason to keep rewards small and pair them with specific praise.
  3. Does teaching children how to play cognitively demanding games improve their educational attainment? Evidence from a randomised controlled trial of chess instruction in England (Jerrim, Macmillan, Micklewright, Sawtell and Wiggins (UCL Institute of Education), funded by the Education Endowment Foundation, 2018). A randomized trial of whole-class chess lessons for children aged 9 and 10 in England. It does not test playing at home by choice.

Sources were checked when this article was written. This article is general education, not medical, diagnostic or legal advice.

Coming soon: MySoarBoard

The Foundation is building a home–school learning board for children in kindergarten through grade 3 that puts ideas like this into daily practice. See what is inside or request an early peek (opens the Foundation's website).