Let children rate their own day first

Why asking a child to rate their own day before they hear an adult’s view builds honest self-checking, and how to do it kindly.

For grown-ups3 min readEvidence: A plausible use of broader research
A child choosing a picture card while an adult listens.

Why this matters

When an adult tells a child how the day went, the child mostly listens. When the child says first, the child has to think. Did I start my work? Did I keep my hands to myself? Was it a good day or a hard one?

That small pause is a skill. It is called self-monitoring: noticing what you did and judging it against a goal. Grown-ups use it all day long. Young children are still learning it, and some children, including many with ADHD, find it especially hard.

What it looks like

  • The child goes first. Before seeing the teacher’s rating, the child rates the same goals. Faces or colors work well for young children.
  • Then compare. Look at the child’s rating and the teacher’s side by side.
  • Talk about differences calmly. “You gave yourself green for starting work. Your teacher gave yellow. What do you remember about that?”
  • Praise honesty, not high marks. A child who says “I had a hard time today” deserves real credit for saying so.
  • Look for change over weeks. Over time, the child’s ratings and the teacher’s often grow closer. That is the skill growing.

What the research says

Guidance from the Education Endowment Foundation looks at how children learn to plan, check and evaluate their own work (source 1). It finds that teaching these habits helps learning in school. It suggests making the steps clear and practicing them often.

A major U.S. guide for kindergarten to grade 5 teachers rates “teach students to monitor and reflect on their own behavior” as moderate evidence (source 2). The same guide rates behavior ratings for feedback as strong evidence. Pairing the two is a natural fit: the child rates first, then gets the adult’s view.

Researchers at Harvard’s Project Zero studied thinking habits (source 3). One finding stands out. Children who could solve a thinking problem when told to often did not notice, on their own, that a problem needed thinking. Noticing the moment mattered as much as ability. Rating your own day is practice in noticing.

What the research does not say

  • Matching the teacher’s rating is a judging skill, not a goal to push up. If points are involved, reward accurate ratings, not high ones.
  • The research comes from classrooms. A self-check at home or in an app applies these ideas; it has not been tested itself.
  • The Project Zero studies were small and with older students. They suggest why noticing matters; they do not prove a routine works for young children.

How to talk about it

Use questions that open thinking, not ones that test.

  • “What made you pick that color?”
  • “What would a green day look like tomorrow?”
  • “Was there a moment you almost got off track, and then got back on?”
  • “What helped you most today?”

If your child rates every day green, do not argue. Ask for one example. If your child rates every day red, look for one good moment together. Either way, the goal is a true picture, kindly told.

Make it fit your child

Some children prefer to point at a face, draw, or tell you out loud. All of those count. Keep the rating private from classmates. Keep it short: under a minute. And keep it the same for a few weeks, so it becomes a habit rather than a test.

Try it this week

For five school days, ask your child to rate their own day on one goal before you see any report. Write both ratings down. On Friday, look at them together and ask, “What do you notice?”

Try it with your child

Sources and how far they apply

  1. Metacognition and Self-Regulated Learning: Guidance Report (Education Endowment Foundation (Quigley, Muijs and Stringer), 2018). Mostly UK school evidence. It supports teaching planning and self-checking; it does not test any particular app or routine at home.
  2. Teacher-Delivered Behavioral Interventions in Grades K-5: A Practice Guide for Educators (WWC 2025001) (What Works Clearinghouse, U.S. Institute of Education Sciences (panel chaired by Kathleen Lynne Lane, December 2024). Written for K–5 classroom teachers; it is about school behavior, not home websites, and it does not cover intensive interventions.
  3. Intelligence in the Wild: A Dispositional View of Intellectual Traits (Perkins, Tishman, Ritchhart, Donis and Andrade, Harvard Graduate School of Education (Educational Psychology Review, 2000). A 25-year-old review by the researchers about their own approach. Their studies were small and with older students.

Sources were checked when this article was written. This article is general education, not medical, diagnostic or legal advice.

Coming soon: MySoarBoard

The Foundation is building a home–school learning board for children in kindergarten through grade 3 that puts ideas like this into daily practice. See what is inside or request an early peek (opens the Foundation's website).