Rewards and praise: keeping motivation alive

How to use points, rewards and praise so they help a child build new habits without crowding out the joy of the activity itself.

For grown-ups3 min readEvidence: A plausible use of broader research
An adult smiling as a child makes a choice.

Why this matters

Sticker charts, points and small prizes are common at home and at school. They can help a child see progress and stay with a new habit. But rewards are not all the same. Used one way, they help. Used another way, they can make a child less interested in the activity itself.

What the research says

A large U.S. guide for kindergarten to grade 5 teachers rates acknowledging expected behavior with positive attention, praise and rewards as strong evidence (source 2). It also gives practical advice. Involve children and their families in choosing rewards. Praise behavior and effort, not ability. Be sincere. Use both objects and experiences as rewards.

A well-known review pooled 128 experiments on rewards and interest (source 1). It found that tangible rewards given for doing or finishing a task tended to lower later interest in that task. The effect was stronger in children, and mainly for tasks they already enjoyed. Positive feedback, such as specific praise, helped interest.

Put together, the message is clear. Rewards can help a child learn a new habit. Keep them small, pair them with real praise, and do not pay a child for something they already love doing.

Praise that works

Specific praise tells a child exactly what they did well.

  • Instead of “good job,” try “You started your reading right away.”
  • Instead of “you are so smart,” try “You tried a different way when the first one did not work.”
  • Instead of “perfect,” try “You checked your answer before you said it.”

Specific praise is free, it never runs out, and it points to something the child can do again.

Using points and rewards well

  • Keep amounts small. A few points for real effort is enough.
  • Let your child choose. Children care more about rewards they picked.
  • Mix in experiences. Extra reading time, choosing dinner or a trip to the park can mean more than a toy.
  • Never take earned points away. Losing what you earned feels unfair and can turn a chart into a fight.
  • Pair every reward with words. “You earned that by starting your homework without a reminder.”
  • Do not pay for joy. If your child already loves drawing or building, let it be its own reward.

What the research does not say

  • The guide is about classrooms, not home reward systems or apps. Home use is a reasonable application.
  • The reward experiments were mostly short lab and school studies.
  • Points alone are not expected to create lasting change. They work best as part of clear goals, feedback and warm praise.

Watch for these signs

  • Your child only does the task when a reward is offered. Fade the reward slowly and keep the praise.
  • Your child argues about points more than doing the task. Simplify the system.
  • Interest in a favorite activity drops after adding rewards. Remove rewards from that activity.

Make progress visible

Children like to see how far they have come. A chart, a jar of marbles or a simple level system can show progress without big prizes. Celebrate milestones with words and time together.

Try it this week

Count how often you say “good job” in one evening. The next evening, replace each one with a specific sentence about what your child did. Notice how your child responds.

Sources and how far they apply

  1. A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation (Deci, Koestner and Ryan, Psychological Bulletin 125(6), 627-668, 1999). Mostly short lab and school experiments. A reason to keep rewards small and pair them with specific praise.
  2. Teacher-Delivered Behavioral Interventions in Grades K-5: A Practice Guide for Educators (WWC 2025001) (What Works Clearinghouse, U.S. Institute of Education Sciences (panel chaired by Kathleen Lynne Lane, December 2024). Written for K–5 classroom teachers; it is about school behavior, not home websites, and it does not cover intensive interventions.

Sources were checked when this article was written. This article is general education, not medical, diagnostic or legal advice.

Coming soon: MySoarBoard

The Foundation is building a home–school learning board for children in kindergarten through grade 3 that puts ideas like this into daily practice. See what is inside or request an early peek (opens the Foundation's website).